I know that on-line learning is becoming
more prevalent but at least on a time scale relevant to us (say 20 years) I don’t
think it is going to kill off face to face training.
I am not being complacent but have the following
views;
1.
Online training sounds good but needs
strong self motivation - I know I am not
doing as much on my on-line Arabic course as I should
2.
People have different learning styles and
the interaction at physical events is appropriate to some – others will be
happy with reading
3.
The time away from the office allows
learning in a focused environment
4.
The time away from the office allows from a
jolly day away from the office (a big thing in the Middle East!)
5.
It is not easy to codify all the relevant
experience and knowledge
6.
Presenters can tailor material to audiences
(currently) better than on line systems
7.
The interaction with other delegates is
often beneficial
8.
Training is often quite a lot of fun – more
than an online version
9.
The advantages of e-learning are cost, ease
of delivery, and consistency of delivery.
However we often irrationally value things we pay more for more than
cheaper things, and the ease of delivery may make it easy to put it off,
consistency can mean a “one size fits all” approach – which as we know means it
actually fits very few.
The same discussion can also apply to
consultancy - why don’t people just read
a book instead of bringing in an expert?
In future will they just go to expert systems? Many of the thing we consult about are
actually known concepts – you can get them from a book – but there is (at least
currently) an advantage to bringing in an external advisor. In future it will be easier to get the data,
but the knowledge of how to apply it will reside in individuals for a while.
So over time I expect there will be a big
shift away from individuals to on-line resources, and the opportunities for
people like us will come in developing and testing innovative ideas and
potentially academic research (assuming students are also mainly being taught
on-line). But that is probably beyond my
timeline. The key differentiators then
would probably be profile (people will pay for a world leading consultant), contacts
(people will hire people they know), style (people hire “people like us” and
people they like), and innovation (something new to give them an edge in a
world where everyone has the same basic information).
William Gibson said “the future is already
here, it’s just not evenly distributed”.
I feel the same about knowledge, and see our role as helping the
distribution process. Books (paper or
online) are not enough.
Your views may differ.
No comments:
Post a Comment